Top 10 Roofing Companies in Williamsburg, Virginia – Reviews, Ratings & Pros and Cons
Whenever you go for a roofing company in Williamburg, you should make sure that the company you are looking for is trustworthy and has a good reviews. Not just that but also this includes understand the climate of Virginia and the local building code issues.
I’ve done some research and found top 10 reputable roofing companies in the Williamburg region. Below should get the basic features of each company, this includes the ratings, location and pros and cons..
Listing Top 10 Roofing Companies Williamsburg
1. Best Choice Roofing
4.6•Roofing contractor
- Location: 309 McLaws Cir STE A, Williamsburg, VA 23185
- GMB Star Rating: 4.6 stars (166 reviews)
- Pros & Cons:
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Nationally-recognized brand with many installations, good track record in Williamsburg. | With a larger brand and many jobs, communication may be less personalized. |
| Specializes in asphalt shingle roofing and weather damage repair, parameters suited to Virginia climate. | Might cost more than smaller local competitors. |
| They emphasise cleanup and disposal of old materials. | Sometimes wait times for scheduling may be longer during busy season. |
2. Streamline Roofing
5.0•Roofing contractor
- Location: 150 Strawberry Plains Rd STE B, Williamsburg, VA 23188
- GMB Star Rating: 5.0 stars (263 reviews)
- Pros & Cons:
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Licensed Class A contractor, Certified “SELECT ShingleMaster” status (manufacturer credential) for quality work. | With such high reviews, they may book out quickly and availability may be limited. |
| Strong positive customer feedback on communication and timely completion. | Being smaller, they may have fewer crews, which could affect large or commercial scale projects. |
| Good fit for both residential and commercial roofs. | If you need very low-cost basic repair, their premium credentials may come at a premium price. |
3. Pyramid Roofing
4.9•Roofing contractor
- Location: 5268 Olde Towne Rd, Williamsburg, VA 23188
- GMB Star Rating: 4.9 stars (345 reviews)
- Pros & Cons:
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Established since 1986 in Virginia; long-term experience in the region. | Some reviews note that communication could be improved in certain projects. |
| A+ rating with BBB, upfront honest pricing, good reputation. | Larger firm size may mean more middle-man steps (sales, supervisors) rather than direct craftsman. |
| Offers both residential and commercial roofing, good warranty options. | For smaller repairs, their overhead might mean slightly higher quote than niche specialists. |
4. R.A. Woodall Roofing
5.0•Roofing contractor
- Location: 1115 Professional Dr Suite 5, Williamsburg, VA 23185
- GMB Star Rating: 5.0 stars (76 reviews)
- Pros & Cons:
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Highly positive local reviews, niche focus on roofs in Williamsburg region. | Less information on large-scale commercial work (may be more residential-focused). |
| Smaller-scale operation often means more direct contact and personal oversight. | For major roof replacements, their resources might be more limited compared to large firms. |
| Good reputation for timely repairs and clean-up. | Might not have as broad a range of specialty roofing materials or styles compared to larger firms. |
5. Williamsburg Roofing Co.
5.0•Roofing contractor
- Location: 402 W Duke of Gloucester St Ste 211, Williamsburg, VA 23185
- GMB Star Rating: 5.0 stars (29 reviews)
- Pros & Cons:
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Local firm with strong emphasis on honesty, integrity, and high standards, good for historic Williamsburg homes. | Smaller review base (fewer reviews) means less data to compare across many projects. |
| Offers residential and commercial roofing, plus gutter work and skylights, which is helpful if you need a full solution. | If you’re looking for rapid large-crew work on a big roof, may be fewer resources. |
| Good for those wanting local attention and potentially more flexible service. | May not have the same marketing or warranty breadth as larger national chains. |
6. Line by Line Roofing
4.7•Roofing contractor
- Location: 312 Lightfoot Rd Suite F, Williamsburg, VA 23188
- GMB Star Rating: 4.7 stars (114 reviews)
- Pros & Cons:
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Expert in roof installation, repair & maintenance; emphasizes correct materials and craftsmanship. | Not BBB-accredited (so you’ll want to check licensing and references carefully). |
| Transparent process with free quotes and good commitment to quality. | Slightly lower rating compared to some others; you may want to ask about consistency of service. |
| Good option for homeowners wanting hands-on service with attention to detail. | For highly complex or commercial roofing systems, may not be as specialized as big firms. |
7. Chase Roofing LLC
4.7•Roofing contractor
- Location: 4504 John Tyler Hwy, Williamsburg, VA 23188
- GMB Star Rating: 4.7 stars (98 reviews)
- Pros & Cons:
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Mid-sized local roofing company with good number of reviews and decent rating. | Some reviews (on third-party lists) date a few years back; you’ll want recent references. |
| Likely more accessible and responsive compared to large national firms. | May not have the same warranty offerings or financing options as the largest companies. |
| Good for standard residential roofing upgrades or repairs. | If you’re doing high-end material replacements (e.g., slate or metal), check their specialization. |
8. Alpine Roofing
4.9•Roofing contractor
- Location: (service area includes) Williamsburg, Yorktown, Newport News — specific address not shown in listing.
- GMB Star Rating: 4.9 stars (37 reviews)
- Pros & Cons:
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Specialized in roof repair and replacement with knowledge of Virginia climate factors (e.g., humidity, heavy rain, historic homes) | Location/address is less clear for Williamsburg; may mean travel or scheduling constraints. |
| Good rating with positive feedback for smaller jobs and attention to detail. | Smaller review base may mean less track record on very large projects. |
| Good choice for homeowners with older/historic homes or those needing nuanced solution. | If you want a major commercial roofing job, you’ll want to verify capacity. |
9. Upward Construction
4.9•Roofing contractor
- Location: 402 W Duke of Gloucester St Ste 210, Williamsburg, VA 23185
- GMB Star Rating: 4.9 stars (42 reviews)
- Pros & Cons:
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Strong local rating, good for combining roofing with other exterior construction/renovation as the name suggests. | May be more general in scope (construction/roofing) rather than purely a roofing-specialist firm—check specialization. |
| Potentially helpful if you want exterior work beyond just the roof (siding, gutters, etc.). | For strict roofing projects you may need to verify their roofing-specific credentials (warranty, manufacturer certification). |
| More flexible service possibilities. | With multi-service firms, roofing may not always be their sole focus; ensure they have roofing crew dedicated. |
10. VA Flat Roofers of Williamsburg
5.0•Roofing contractor
- Location: (Specific address not listed) Williamsburg, VA area.
- GMB Star Rating: 5.0 stars (25 reviews)
- Pros & Cons:
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Specialized in flat-roof systems (which many homeowners or commercial buildings in the area need). | If your roof is a steep-slope shingle type (typical residential), their specialization may mean you’ll want to confirm they handle that as well. |
| Excellent rating though fewer reviews; niche specialization may mean strong expertise in that area. | Fewer reviews means less breadth of demonstrated work to browse; you’ll want to ask for past examples. |
| Good fit for commercial or townhouse/condo style flat roofing jobs. | For standard homes you might have more choice among firms with broader roofing portfolios. |
Why getting the right roofer in williamsburg matters a lot?
Summers, storms and the age of local housing stock mean the roofing construction needs to know how to deal with these problems.
If you are living in that area you would know that homes in williamsburg region are very old and style to match historic aesthetics therefore choosing someone who is sensitive to appearance is essential.
Many of us doesn’t know that Virginia requires proper roofing licencing and a serious company will offer a good workmanship this includes warranty and manufacturing material warranties too.
Your roof can be a major investment and a major part of your home’s value and protection.
Therefore choosing the right roofer in wilsonburg isn’t just about finding the lowest bid but about matching the project needs with right expertise, material and reputation.
Final words
If I were to choose the best roofing companies in wilsonburg then I would start by contacting three or four companies listed above. After that I would have asked them for the such thing like a detailed estimate, review of past local work, if they have licence or not and if they provide insurance, ask about the material used especially if you want something beyond standards Asphalt shingles.
So from the list above you can go any of four or maybe five, try contacting them and choose the best one according to your needs. It’s what doing your homework because the roof is a long term investment in your home liability. Happy roofing.
Also Read: